The Edits / Short Versions - www.abba4ever.com

iphpbb - Forenarchiv: Archivbeitrag des Forums www.abba4ever.com

Verfügbare Informationen zu "The Edits / Short Versions"

Qualität des Beitrags:
Beteiligte Poster: Marcus - supertrouper - Maxi-saxi - ABBAFANUSA - drimnagh - Toni
Forum: www.abba4ever.com
Forenbeschreibung: The World-Spanning ABBA Fan Online Community - Welcome!
aus dem Unterforum: The Music
Antworten: 8
Forum gestartet am: Dienstag 10.10.2006
Sprache: englisch
Link zum Originaltopic: The Edits / Short Versions
Letzte Antwort: vor 1 Jahr, 5 Monaten, 11 Tagen, 43 Minuten

Alle Beiträge und Antworten

Marcus - 30.04.2007, 21:23
The Edits / Short Versions
How can they turn The name of the game into a 2.48 thing? Why did some people even bother cutting them down so harsh?

supertrouper - 30.04.2007, 21:31

Personally, I hate edits. I can understand why some are done for single re-leases, but I never listen to them. To me, the songs are not complete. I can only imagine how TNOTG would sound cut so drastically :(

Anthony.

Marcus - 30.04.2007, 21:44

I understand it when they edit but not that harsh. I mean they lose too much of the original. If there is a clever way to do it, then its okay. :)

Maxi-saxi - 01.05.2007, 05:36

I'm in to minds about edits.

i know in some TV Shows For Instance The German Show ere they Preformed Cassandra, Under Attack and The Day Before You Came, all 3 songs were edited in some way and Under Attack had the Gold sudden ending, which I like.

Same as The Day Before You Came, and I know ABBA mixed at least 3 different versions of Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! A Man After Midnight.

One mix of course for the Video clip . Another for the Album And a third for TV program's

Some of them are pretty harsh, But a few of them are OK.

Maxi-saxi

ABBAFANUSA - 01.05.2007, 06:27

What is the 2:48 version on?

The worst one I've heard is the Mexican 45 of "The Visitors"
The best edit I've heard is the US Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!, I think it was done well.

If anyone wants to hear them, just email me.

drimnagh - 01.05.2007, 13:59

Can't stand the edits! Gimme back Eagle (complete version with guitar solo) and stop messing with The Name Of The Game! I love extended versions- in particular The Visitors, LAYLOM, On and ON And On, etc.

So, lets have all the missing verses, etc.

I DO understand why they do it sometimes as in Eagle for 'Gold', but I always liked Lasse Wellanders guitar solo.

Joe

Maxi-saxi - 02.05.2007, 06:08

ABBAFANUSA wrote: What is the 2:48 version on?

The worst one I've heard is the Mexican 45 of "The Visitors"
The best edit I've heard is the US Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!, I think it was done well.

If anyone wants to hear them, just email me.

I know, I have the Mexican 45 Of The Visitors and it's shocking.

Actually I have the complete Mexican 45's set on vinyl and Albums. I brought these of a RCA Mexican Rep. I also have a few singles doubled up as a couple of them are Promotional ones with press release's in them.

Maxi-saxi

Toni - 03.05.2007, 17:53

I guess they did it because on early CD-years there wasnŽt enough place to put the complete song on it.

Of course I totally agree with you, I never would edit an ABBA song. I want to hear every single note from the beginning to the end! :D

Toni :wink:

Mit folgendem Code, können Sie den Beitrag ganz bequem auf ihrer Homepage verlinken