Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

www.abba4ever.com

Verfügbare Informationen zu "Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version.."

Qualität des Beitrags:
Beteiligte Poster: Maxi-saxi - spong - Fire&Ice - abbascots - MarryMeAgnetha - kitty-cat - Toni - Carribean
Forum: www.abba4ever.com
Forenbeschreibung: The World-Spanning ABBA Fan Online Community - Welcome!
aus dem Unterforum: The Music
Antworten: 14
Forum gestartet am: Dienstag 10.10.2006
Sprache: englisch
Link zum Originaltopic: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..
Letzte Antwort: vor 6 Jahren, 2 Monaten, 27 Tagen, 11 Stunden, 42 Minuten

Alle Beiträge und Antworten zu "Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version.."

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Maxi-saxi - 23.02.2007, 23:43
Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..
I like this song very much But I was wanting to know What version do you like better

Frida And Bjorns Version Abba The Movie or ABBA On ABBAdabbado?

The Movie version has a heavier sound to it and the earlier version is ABBA and I like it as well.

I guess you really can't compare them both BUT do you have a favourite.

Or are you like me and like both.

Maxi-saxi :wink:

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

spong - 24.02.2007, 01:09

hello

sitting on the fence time for me too.
i do like heavy music but really i do not find too much of a difference to like one more than the other.

gary :D

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Fire&Ice - 24.02.2007, 02:22

Gimme the Movie version any time! Both musically and visually!

However, I must say the live Abbadabbadoo version is great as well, especially because I am a fan of live recordings - this one sounds just like on the record.

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

abbascots - 24.02.2007, 03:37

Hello Maxi-saxi
Frida and Bjorns performance on Abba the movie is Fantastic,This has to be one of my fave Frida performances ever so i would say Abba the movie
a very energetic song with a spectacular stage show from Frida and Bjorn
Regards johnsteven :)

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Maxi-saxi - 25.02.2007, 05:39

Thank's Fire&Ice, Sponge and Abbascots, I enjoyed your comments.

Maxi-saxi

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

MarryMeAgnetha - 26.02.2007, 01:22

Fire&Ice wrote: Gimme the Movie version any time! Both musically and visually!

However, I must say the live Abbadabbadoo version is great as well, especially because I am a fan of live recordings - this one sounds just like on the record.

It sounds just like the record because ABBA were just miming to the record, which I'm sure you already knew.

The record sounded fine, but like you, I really prefer the "live", Movie version.

--Daniel

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Fire&Ice - 26.02.2007, 01:31

MarryMeAgnetha wrote:
It sounds just like the record because ABBA were just miming to the record, which I'm sure you already knew.

There are two live recordings in Abbadabbadoo - Dum dum diddle and Why did it have to be me. I remember reading some place that Abba were asked to do some live singing for the programme and they did. As far as I know, these two weren't mimed. Someone correct me if I am wrong.

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Maxi-saxi - 26.02.2007, 01:49

No way were they mimed! They were both sung live, You can tell that.

It even states in the booklet by the guy that made the TV Show and Carl Magnus Palm they were sung live these 2 tracks.
So that is why they are very special.

Maxi-saxi

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

MarryMeAgnetha - 26.02.2007, 01:56

OK, I stand corrected then. I haven't watched it in a while, if you can believe that. ABBA mimed so many of their TV appearances I incorrectly assumed that this was just another one without watching it first. ( :oops: The ONE time I don't check before shooting off my mouth...!)

--Daniel

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Maxi-saxi - 26.02.2007, 02:11

Hope I did not offend you Daniel, please accept my appologies if I did.
But I can understand where you are coming from. ABBA miming to so many songs, even there so called live Album was a touched up studio job, so to speak.

But it is nice to finally see ABBA live with these 2 songs, I think it was a shame that not more were recorded.

Maxi-saxi :wink:

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

MarryMeAgnetha - 26.02.2007, 09:18

Maxi (and Ivana),

By all means thank you for setting the record straight. You don't have to apologize for being knowledgeable and accurate!

--Daniel

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

kitty-cat - 26.02.2007, 11:08

I like them both, but i think i prefer The Move version becaue it is live, whereas on the abbadabbadoo version they are miming. But the performances are both great.

Gill xx

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Toni - 26.02.2007, 20:15

Yes, both versions sound well.

The Movie-Version is very interesting, because of the Frida-solos. I think she had really much fun, when she performed it. I really like it.

The ABBA-dabba-doo-version is fantastic, too. I like it a bit more because the complete group is acting, like in the studio version.

Toni :)

Re: Why Did It Have To Be Me! Movie or TV Special Version..

Carribean - 26.02.2007, 22:53

Both versions are live with some studio help afterwards and I prefer the ABBADabbaDoo version.

Mit folgendem Code, können Sie den Beitrag ganz bequem auf ihrer Homepage verlinken